Why Memoir Drafts Attract Certain Mistakes

Life writing — memoir, autobiography, family history — is written by people with something to say and little appetite for grammatical theory. That is as it should be. But memoir has a distinctive grammar problem: it is written in the voice of a person remembering, so the sentences often tumble out the way speech does. That energy is a strength. It also produces a handful of recurring errors that can distract a reader at precisely the moment you want them absorbed.

The good news is that most of these are easy to spot once you know what you are looking for. This article covers the mistakes that appear again and again in life-writing drafts, and how to fix each one before you send the manuscript to a copy-editor.

Comma Splices: When Two Sentences Share One Comma

A comma splice is two complete sentences joined by nothing more than a comma. It is the most common error in memoir drafts, because we write the way we speak, and in speech a pause does the work that a full stop or a conjunction does in print.

Here is one: I left the house at six, the bus was already late. Both halves could stand alone. Three clean repairs are available:

  • Use a full stop: I left the house at six. The bus was already late.
  • Join with a conjunction: I left the house at six, but the bus was already late.
  • Use a semicolon when the two halves are closely linked: I left the house at six; the bus was already late.

Splices are sometimes used deliberately for a breathless rhythm — 'He came home, he slept for a day, he left again' — and in dialogue that can work well. The rule is simple: the splice should be a choice, not an accident.

Dangling and Misplaced Modifiers

A modifier at the start of a sentence must describe the subject that follows the opening comma. When it does not, you have a dangler — and in life writing they are usually affectionate and unintentionally comic.

Born in a small terraced house in Leeds, my grandmother's stories always began with the smell of coal smoke. As written, it was the stories that were born in Leeds. Name the person in the main clause and the sentence rights itself: Born in a small terraced house in Leeds, my grandmother always began her stories with the smell of coal smoke.

Misplaced modifiers are the cousin of the dangler — the descriptive word has landed beside the wrong thing. I nearly lost those letters for forty years means something quite different from I lost those letters for nearly forty years. Watch for only, nearly, almost and just, and put each one next to the word it actually modifies.

Tense Shifts and the Shape of Memory

Memoir works with at least three time layers: the writing present, the remembered past, and reflection upon both. Confusion arises when you slip between them without signalling. I walked into the shop and the bell rings. The reader stumbles, because the ground has moved underfoot.

Two habits help. First, choose one tense for the body of a scene and keep it — usually the simple past — switching to the present only for a deliberate, sustained effect. Second, use the past perfect (had plus past participle) to step further back when you need to: By the time I arrived, she had already sold the house. Use it sparingly; a paragraph of hads grows heavy.

For repeated childhood actions, the habitual past is a useful tool: Every summer we would walk down to the reservoir and swim until our lips turned blue. Just do not let would drift into scenes describing a single afternoon.

Small Tripwires Worth Their Own Pass

A short list of the smaller faults that repay a dedicated read-through:

  • It's and its. It's is short for 'it is'; its shows possession. Life writing is full of both.
  • Homophones. Their/there/they're, your/you're, passed/past, lead/led. Spellcheck will not catch these.
  • Family plurals and possessives. The family becomes the Evanses, and their house is the Evanses' house.
  • Decades. Write the 1960s, not 'the 1960's'. No apostrophe.
  • Hyphens that change meaning. A man-eating tiger is not a man eating tiger. Compound adjectives before a noun usually take a hyphen: a well-kept garden, but the garden was well kept.

Reading Aloud, Then Editing in Passes

Reading aloud is the most reliable editing tool available to you, and it costs nothing. The eye forgives; the ear does not. Where a comma splice lurks, you will hear yourself run out of breath or pause where no punctuation exists. Where a modifier dangles, the sentence will sound faintly ridiculous — which is exactly the information you need.

Read at a natural speaking pace, not a scanning pace. Slow down over commas and give dialogue its own voice. If a sentence trips you twice, mark it and move on rather than fixing it on the spot.

Then edit in separate passes, one concern at a time, because the brain cannot hold everything at once:

  • Structure: does each scene belong, and does it start and finish where it should?
  • Sentences: comma splices, danglers, tense shifts.
  • The small tripwires listed above.
  • Read the final version aloud from beginning to end, ideally over several days.

When you self-publish, you carry the responsibility a publisher's editor would once have shared. That is a reason for a little method, not for anxiety. Fix the splices, name your subjects, settle your tenses, and read the whole thing aloud. Your story will arrive on the page sounding like you — only clearer.

About Author Graphic Designer

Silveredit An honest, everyday look at the things that make life a little better — with advice you can actually use.

Showing 16 verified guest comments

0123456789 image

Soldman Kell

April 25, 2019 at 10:46 am

"The worst hotel ever"

Take in the iconic skyline and visit the neighbourhood hangouts that you've only ever seen on TV. Take in the iconic skyline and visit the neighbourhood.

image

Burson Lesson

April 25, 2019 at 10:46 am

"Was too noisy and not suitable for business meetings"

Take in the iconic skyline and visit the neighbourhood hangouts that you've only ever seen on TV. Take in the iconic skyline and visit the neighbourhood.

Write a Review

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Want to be notified when we launch a new template or an udpate. Just sign up and we'll send you a notification by email.

Night
Day